Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Top Teachers List




This series of posts will be dedicated to some of the most influential teachers I have had thus far in my life.
 
Top Teacher #1: J.R.
 
At this time of year, I always take a few moments to reduce the size of my bloated files by taking out all information that I will not be needing for the next school year. It's really gratifying, especially, to clear out those "Memo" files and extremely entertaining to sift through the "Personal" file. It's at this time that I get to look over the cards and pictures and other personal items that I collected throughout the year, thinking about which ones still have meaning and which will have meaning in future years. Now that I've got a few years under my belt, I also like to look through my "personal" files from past years of teaching. My 2005-2006 school year file has an entire folder stuffed into it marked with a student's name who will hereby be referred to as "JR".
 
Each school year, it seems, there is one student who gets their own file, filled with memories of what made them particulary challenging. Inevitably there are old planning documents, behavior plans, drawings or pictures, and funny writing assignments stuffed in there... "JR" was the first student who got his own file and in the past five years I have found myself unable to throw away a single scrap.
 
When I was in college, I would tell anyone who would ask that I would never teach a primary grade, no matter how much I was paid. The reality of finding a job, however, landed me as a second grade teacher in a small rural school in south central Pennsylvania. I convinced myself that second grade was not primary, put on a brave face, and smiled and said "guess" when a student would ask me age (21), rather than give myself away. Despite the challenges, the first week of school went quite well and I started to gain some confidence. And then I got a new student.
 
JR came to me from the school district I grew up in. He looked innocent enough at first. After about 10 minutes in my classroom, however, he had used at least three 4-letter words, winked and licked his lips at a particularly shy girl, and my room began to smell alarmingly like motor oil.
 
It took about four days for me to fully grasp that JR was a part of my class. He would not be leaving. He would not be absent. My hands (because I had to hold his hand not only in the hallway, but pretty much all day every day) would smell like motor oil for the entire year. The thought came crashing down on me during a brief conversation with my guidance counselor, a few minutes before picking my students up from recess. To my horror, I actually started bawling.
 
It's funny. I've always been a reflective person, a journal keeper. I set out that school year to record the ups and downs of being a new teacher. I wrote a beautiful entry just before the parents arrived on Back-To-School night before the year began. I wrote again the day that I realized the impact JR would have on my life. I did not write again until the 2006-2007 school year.
 
In the early days of that year, I couldn't stop to think for even a few moments, lest I suffer from a panic attack or nervous breakdown. Parents were calling me, telling me they had to have "the talk" with their seven year old because of a curious comment JR made to them. He got banned from the playground, the cafeteria, specials, because any time there weren't adult eyes on him he made sly comments to other kids or ate something he should not. So JR became my full-time companion. We were together, all the time, for 9 straight months.
 
I quickly became disenchanted with the "identification" process that promised to remove JR from my room. It dawned on me that only I could control the destiny of my classroom. I started to come up with ideas to not only keep JR busy, but to actually help him learn. We started simple... I created some word sorts using the "a" sound, the only vowel he could recognize. We sorted cards between long a and short a. The first time I left him alone with his word sort, he ate it. The entire thing. Swallowed it. I was shocked, but I printed another and we tried again.
 
It took almost 2 months before we moved on to "e", another month before "i" and I'm pretty sure we never got to"u" by the end of the year, but JR began to develop the habit of sitting down and doing his sort once a day. This afforded me about 8 minutes of peace a day.
 
Now that Language Arts was covered, we moved on to math. JR was intrigued by the timed math tests my students took each day. At first he only wanted to control the timer because it made him feel important and a part of things, the most important currency I could use with him, I found. Eventually, though, he wanted to try too. Again, we started simple. His first timed math test was tracing numbers, followed by filling in the next number in the sequence. By the end of the year he could do one digit numbers plus 1. I now had 10 minutes of peace a day.
 
Thinking back, I don't think I ever got more than that. JR is now bussed to another school where, I am told, he is a star student compared to some others in the class. It took him calling the school psychologist the b-word and stomping on his foot, plus a case of a library book covered in human urine to even get him through the identification process, a process that took until May of the 2005-2006 school year. JR was in my room full time for one full school year. I still cringe a little when I smell motor oil. But you know what? This child taught me one of the most powerful lessons of my teaching career.
 
You are on your own.
 
There are "services", sure. They are not miracles and they are not guarenteed. Often times, the providers of said services know even less than you do, which is a hard pill for a 21 year old to swallow. You make small strides and they never feel like enough, but they are. I was worried about my class that year, that they would be traumatized, that they would be hurt or damaged by JR. In fact, those same students as fourth graders actually said, "Who?" when I asked them if they remembered their former classmate. With hindsight to guide me, that is enough for me to know I accomplished something that year. My second graders learned and were safe, JR's time was only wasted for 5 hours and 50 minutes each day and I became an independent teacher, a problem solver, and someone who never looks to someone else to solve the mysteries of my classroom.

Friday, June 11, 2010

The Rube Goldberg-izing of Education


Public Education: Making the Simple Complex since 1852

Earlier this school year, my fourth grade gifted cluster classes were studying simple machines. As a culminating project, they created Rube Goldberg-esque machines, using levers, pulleys, etc. to make a simple task (such as bouncing a ball or unwrapping a piece of candy) more complex.

Recently I got to thinking about how our public education system routinely "Rube Goldberg-izes" curriculum, procedures, accountability measures, and just about anything they can get their hands on. Think back to the last excrutiating faculty meeting you attended, where nearly 20 minutes was spent determining the best solution for the lunch box pick up problem or the seating arrangement in the auditorium. Even more frustrating (and terrifying)- take a close look at one of your teaching manuals and read an entire page from top to bottom, left to right. Amazing how trivialized one skill can become!

Imagine the instructional time that could be saved by streamlining and de-Goldberizing our schools! Collaboration time could be spent analyzing student work, providing constructive feedback to colleagues, or (gasp!) differntiating instruction based on data. Nevermind that the putty we are using to hold up our posters keeps peeling or a colleague's birthday is coming and we have to come up with a clever gift. Forget that we ran out of post-its earlier than expected and there are typos in the curriculum guide written by a notoriously incompetent (yet frequently promoted) specialist. Who cares that our second graders keep tattling and the fifth graders can't seem to keep quiet in the restrooms?

The work of teaching is more important than all of these silly things. It should not take 13 steps to wipe our face with a napkin, or, the educational equivalent: get our students to write the proper heading on their page. Our time would be better spent making the complex more simple. Helping students understand place value is hard! There are multiple steps that can be taken to get to the final product of kids being about to compute with large numbers.

With the tight budgets we are working with today, our resources need to be used as efficiently as possible. Personally, I'd rather my tax dollars pay for a Place-Value machine rather than a Heading Writer.

Friday, June 4, 2010

The Inclination to "Teach"



When I was a kid, I taught my brother how to roller skate.

This sounds innocent enough, but if you ask him about it, he will shudder and cringe. You see, my brother already knew how to roller skate.

We had our lessons in the garage when one or both of my parents' cars were gone. The floor was smooth and flat, creating the perfect surface for skill practice. I spent hours planning the lessons, determining what precise skills he needed to work on and developing drills that would help him isolate that particular skill.

The lessons would begin, usually to music, with me demonstrating and him mimicking the drill. Most often, he was perfect the first time. This was frustrating to me. So I picked apart his performance until he had no clue what it was I was trying to get him to accomplish. Now this was something I could work with! I would create impassioned speeches about believing in oneself, practicing until there was nothing less to practice and then practicing some more.

This went on for an entire summer. 3 months of torture for my poor baby brother.

Looking back, it's not difficult to see why I felt the need to teach my brother to roller skate. I had experienced terrible failure that school year. My teacher did not like me and I knew it. I had the skills I needed before I set foot in that classroom. This frustrated her. She proceeded to pick apart my performance until I no longer knew what it was she wanted me to do. She drilled me, I failed... to music.

If You're Standing Still, You're Moving Backwards.


"Yesterday's classrooms are not coming back. Nor should they return... Getting everyone to agree on that, or anything else, can be a challenge."

~Elaine Wilmore